Set light year as length unit, year as time unit, kg as mass unit.
With a 1-dimension pure radial movement , let then
light movement
aka
a mass object movement
Note that Special Relativity is the case when is super large. Newton physics is further the case when is small and accordingly .
To calculate of an object moving toward the gravity center:
Therefore,
Light movement is like a mass object movement with infinite energy per unit mass . An almost idle object which has super large away from a gravity's center has
rescue story
Let . Alice who falls from and caught at by Bob who starts at with high initial speed meaning Bob's super large . Typically is a function of the so that the engine can change it according to where is the acceleration, constant or not, with respect to proper time of the spaceship, but here the rescue spaceship is modeled as an initial high speed then free-fall.
Starting free-fall at zero speed, Alice's must be such that:
Therefore,
Alice falling, formula :
Alice SOS signal to the space station, formula :
Bob's rescue, formula :
To make the rescue possible, say, a 10 years preparation means:
aka
Therefore must be positive:
One can see the larger the and the smaller the , the larger the difference. Hence, to check the rescue possibility, consider the case of meaning Bob at light speed and meaning as late rescues as possible. It is:
Meaning, Bob spaceship station cannot be too far away from where Alice starts falling, formula whose two times of the left side minus the right side is the :
Alice will never really fall into the horizon and her headlamp is always seen by Bob although Bob must be long-lived to see the light. But, once is violated, any rescue information that Bob sends to Alice will not be seen by Alice. is typically large. For the Sun, on its surface 695700 km away from the center and if all the mass is within its horizon.
plot
Alice and the space station is established beside the supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy for the purpose of research. The space station is away from the black hole's horizon. Alice's spaceship loses engine power and starts free-falling at away from the horizon. Alice has a beam-me-up machine which can encode the information of her body and her mind and transmit it back to the space station and then recreate the body and the mind but she needs a passing code to activate the task and the passing code is transmitted from the space station to Alice for the rescue. The black hole has horizon meters. The left of is aka aka meters away from the horizon. Luckily, location of the space station satisfies this condition.
1 light-year is meter so the horizon is light-year. The allowed time for rescue preparation is year beyond which Bob space station has no way to rescue Alice back.
When the beam-me-up method is not an option but a powerful spaceship with aka for the rescue, the max preparation time is year. If the preparation time is actually 0.1 year, less than 0.201 therefore feasible, then Alice would be caught up at aka away from the horizon by this powerful spaceship: year.
However, the required time back to the space station could be quite large due to the term in if is near zero.
compared with classic Newton
Alice's falling
no initial speed at in both theories
:
Let
Ratio of Alice's falling, :
The General Relativity is the same as Newton is in the sense of constant and , then the ratio is:
Further, calculate as . By L'Hôpital rule,
Therefore,
Alice SOS
:
Let
:
Bob's rescue
Both with unit mass energy at in both theories. But Newton does not count mass as energy, so plus 1 to Newton's to be compatible with General Relativity.
:
Let
Ratio of Bob's rescue, :
Therefore,